For this text, CNN appeared into 40 of the claims Biden produced from January 20 by February 19. Our reality checks are beneath — inaccurate claims first; then the claims which can be disputed, sophisticated, or on which Biden may have been clearer if he had added some extra context; then the claims that we will merely name correct.
We invited the White Home to touch upon our findings. The White Home supplied feedback solely on the situation of anonymity. For equity, now we have included these nameless feedback in circumstances the place they assist clarify the place Biden was coming from.
Walter Reed visits
Vaccines to neighborhood well being facilities
Biden’s journey with Xi Jinping
The White Home official instructed CNN that Biden was making “a reference to the whole journey forwards and backwards — each internally within the US and China, and in addition to internationally — for conferences they held collectively. Some journey was in parallel, some was individually to joint locations.” However that could be very totally different than touring “with” Xi, particularly within the context a degree about how acquainted he’s with Xi.
The plan for pharmacies
“Once we first began speaking to the Biden staff throughout the transition, it was unclear what the federal pharmacy partnership program was going to seem like, and key particulars…had been lacking. These particulars had been crucial for us, clearly, as we would have liked to be ready to activate. What we have seen during the last a number of weeks is a transparent nationwide plan emerge,” mentioned a supply at one firm taking part within the partnership program.
A White Home official — a unique official than the one who responded to our different queries — mentioned that when the transition staff approached main pharmacies to ask what the specifics of the federal partnership program had been, “They had been like, ‘We do not know. We had been going to ask you guys this query.'”
Suicide and the pandemic
Details First: This declare is untimely as a result of full nationwide information on suicide within the final 12 months just isn’t but out there, two specialists on the topic instructed CNN. Dr. Joshua Gordon, director of the Nationwide Institute of Psychological Well being, which is a part of the federal Nationwide Institutes of Well being, mentioned in an interview that whereas it is rather clear that surveys present that suicidal ideas have elevated amongst Individuals throughout the pandemic, it’s not clear if this improve has translated to a nationwide improve in folks truly going by with the act; he mentioned “we at all times have a look at survey information with a grain of salt,” since there’s a lot it can not inform us, and there are additionally some indications that the variety of folks reaching out for assistance is up. “If we have a look at deaths from suicide, the information to date that now we have out there doesn’t but present a rise for 2020,” Gordon mentioned.
Gordon additionally mentioned that the psychological well being penalties of disasters are sometimes “not totally realized till the catastrophe is over,” so it’s potential that the influence of the pandemic may present up in suicide information after the quick menace of the virus itself has handed.
All of that’s truthful sufficient. Nevertheless it would not change the truth that we do not but know for certain whether or not Biden’s common declare that “suicides are up” is right.
Biden’s position within the 2009 stimulus talks
Biden did not declare that he was the one particular person accountable for securing the three Republicans’ votes, so his declare is not false. However he would’ve been extra correct if he had made clear he was a part of a staff and if he had not prompt that the three Republicans flip-flopped on the invoice.
Specter died in 2012. Snowe left workplace in 2013, and her institute didn’t reply to a request for remark.
Starvation in January
Details First: Biden has an inexpensive factual foundation for this declare, but it surely’s price noting that the accuracy of the “$40 billion” determine is dependent upon what you contemplate a “handout to Large Oil” and what time interval you’re looking at.
Biden’s “$40 billion” determine could be very near not less than one estimate for annual US subsidies for fossil fuels. The estimate, offered to CNN by the analysis and advocacy group Oil Change Worldwide, which seeks to transition away from fossil fuels, is $39.4 billion. That $39.4 billion determine, nevertheless, additionally contains subsidies for coal (so not simply to “Large Oil”), depends largely on figures from 2015 and 2016, and contains billions in subsidies from state governments (not solely the federal authorities).
Masks and lives
Trump and well being care
Details First: This wants context. Actions taken by the Trump administration did make it tougher for folks to enroll in the Reasonably priced Care Act or qualify for Medicaid. The query of whether or not these actions additionally made protection costlier is extra advanced.
In accordance with Robin Rudowitz, Co-Director of the Kaiser Household Basis’s Program on Medicaid and the Uninsured, the Trump administration’s proposals and actions “largely centered round limiting the scope of Medicaid protection.”
For instance, in a historic step, the Trump administration allowed states to use for waivers to require sure Medicaid recipients to work, volunteer, take courses or seek for jobs with the intention to obtain protection. A dozen states acquired permission to take action. About 18,000 folks had been stripped of their insurance coverage in Arkansas — the one state to completely implement the principles earlier than being stopped by a federal decide — inside a number of months of the mandate taking impact. The Supreme Court docket agreed in December to listen to the case.
– CNN’s Tami Luhby contributed to this merchandise.
Biden getting ‘shot at’
Details First: What counts as being “shot at” is subjective, however there’s sufficient proof for Biden’s imprecise declare that we are saying it’s considerably correct at minimal. The White Home pointed to 5 incidents throughout Biden’s profession as senator and vp, not less than two of them corroborated by media shops.
The White Home despatched CNN a listing of three different incidents Biden says occurred: one other Inexperienced Zone mortar incident in 2005, an incident in 2005 by which Biden mentioned a bullet narrowly missed a helicopter carrying him from the Inexperienced Zone to the Baghdad airport, and an incident in 2004 by which Biden mentioned he was leaving Iraq in a navy aircraft that needed to take evasive motion after its missile warning system was activated.
He may have been extra exact then and now. Nonetheless, his declare that he has been with American diplomats as they had been “shot at” just isn’t baseless.
Racial disparities and the pandemic
The up to date CDC information exhibits that, by January 30, Black folks had died of Covid-19 at 1.9 instances the speed of White folks, down from 2.8 instances within the earlier information. Latino folks had died at 2.3 instances the speed of White folks, additionally down from 2.8 instances within the earlier information.
Attitudes about local weather change
“During the last decade, we have seen little progress within the shares of Republicans and Republican-leaning independents who view local weather change as a serious menace to the U.S. or name it a prime precedence for the president and Congress,” Cary Funk, Pew’s director of science and society analysis, mentioned in an e mail.
Pew requested all respondents about “world warming” from 2008 to 2014. In 2015, it requested half of respondents about “world warming” and half about “local weather change.” From 2016 onward, it has requested all respondents about “local weather change.”
Local weather change and the navy
Listed below are another claims Biden was right about: